Dairy-Free Caesar Dressing (Whole30, Keto)

This astoundingly easy dairy-free Whole30 Caesar dressing tastes just like the original: creamy, tangy, garlicky, and bursting with umami! Make some, and I guarantee you’ll want to spoon it on everything!

Are you on a Whole30, but missing a crisp and delicious Caesar salad? Whip up this super simple yet umami-packed dairy-free Caesar dressing and you can toss yourself a tasty salad EVERY night!

My younger son, Ollie, is not a big fan of vegetables, but he loves a good Caesar salad. And I mean LOVES. Henry once took him to an Italian restaurant in between basketball tournament games, thinking Ollie would want to load up on carbs in the form of gluten-free pasta—something Ollie normally loves. But instead, Ollie ordered a Caesar salad with chicken. Why? “BECAUSE IT’S THE BEST SALAD” was his response. “Also, I don’t want to stuff myself with pasta before my next game.”

When I was testing out this recipe, I knew Ollie was going to be my toughest critic, so I held my breath when he tasted my dressing on a homemade paleo Caesar salad for the first time. To my surprise, he exclaimed that it tastes like the real deal—and then asked for more! Yahoo!

Plus, the beauty of this dairy free Caesar dressing recipe is that you simply measure out some store-bought Whole30-compatible ingredients, dump them in a jar or bowl, whisk it up, and ta-da: amazing dairy-free Caesar dressing in minutes!

NO PARMESAN CHEESE, NO PROBLEM!

Caesar dressing is so popular and delicious because it is an example of umami synergy in action—when you combine a few umami-containing ingredients in a dish, the amount of deliciousness increases exponentially! The combination of egg yolks (in the mayonnaise), parmesan cheese, Worcestershire sauce, and anchovies makes Caesar salad dressing over-the-top delicious; if you leave one out, the resulting dressing is lacking in flavor.

When I was tinkering with a dairy-free and Whole30 Caesar dressing, I made sure to substitute high umami ingredients for the non-Whole30 compliant ones in the original. Try this delicious dressing and I bet it’ll be hard to taste the difference!

CAN YOU MAKE A VEGAN CAESAR SALAD DRESSING?

Yes, but it will be slightly less nomtastic without the anchovies, eggs, and fish sauce. If veganism is your thing, I recommend buying a vegan store-bought mayonnaise with Whole30-compatible ingredients, increasing the amount of nutritional yeast to 3½ tablespoons, and bumping the amount of coconut aminos to 1½ tablespoons. (The notes section of the printable recipe card below will have exact ingredients amounts listed.)

INGREDIENTS FOR THIS DAIRY FREE CAESAR DRESSING

• Whole30-compatible mayonnaise: By using a store-bought avocado oil mayonnaise, you won’t need to worry about the sauce breaking or forming a proper emulsion! The Whole30-compatible brands I use are Primal Kitchen Foods and Chosen Foods. There’s even a vegan Whole30 mayonnaise from Primal Kitchen if you’re avoiding eggs.
• Extra virgin olive oil
• Nutritional yeast: I love using these yellow flakes to impart a cheesy flavor to the dressing in place of the parmesan cheese. My favorite brand is Bragg.  It will add a yellowish hue to the sauce, though.
• Dijon mustard: Check the labels to make sure the ingredients are Whole30-compatible (e.g., no wine or sugar!).
• Lemon juice
• White wine vinegar: I like the combination of fresh lemon juice and vinegar to add the proper tartness to the dressing. You can use red wine vinegar or apple cider vinegar in place of white wine vinegar.
• Coconut aminos: I use this in place of Worcestershire sauce—it adds savoriness and sweetness to the dressing.
• Red Boat fish sauce or flat anchovy fillets in olive oil or anchovy paste: I know some of you are skeeved out by anchovies, but they add a punch of umami and saltiness that’s irreplaceable. (Besides, you know that anchovies are an essential ingredient in classic Caesar dressing, right?) That said, you can easily use fish sauce or anchovy paste if you don’t have any anchovy fillets in your pantry.
• Garlic: Even if you love garlic, one small raw garlic is plenty in this dressing.
• Black pepper

HOW TO MAKE THIS DAIRY FREE CAESAR DRESSING

Measure out all the ingredients and place them in a quart-size mason jar, blender cup, or high-sided bowl.

Blend until smooth with an immersion blender! (Alternatively, you can roll up your sleeves and whisk everything together. But who wants to do that?)

Taste and adjust the seasoning if necessary.

HOW TO STORE WHOLE30 CAESAR SALAD DRESSING?

This amazing Caesar dressing can be stored in a sealed container in the fridge for up to a week. If it solidifies in the refrigerator, shake well  and let it warm slightly at room temperature before using.

HOW TO USE THIS CAESAR DRESSING

If you want to make a Whole30 Caesar salad, toss some romaine lettuce leaves with a little salt and spoonfuls of this creamy Caesar dressing. Then, top the salad with some crispy shallots to mimic the croutons! You can also add your favorite cooked protein, like chicken, shrimp, salmon, or steak, to make this an entree salad.